Where Delicious Delights Disappear!
  702 Raspberry Street, Erie, Pa 814-218-3313
  126 West 9th Street, Erie, Pa 
  Erie's Best Cookies!
  1-888-439-8619

The Magic Cookie Company Bake Shoppe 

Click here to edit subtitle

Testimonials

Join our Cookie Club

  • Subscribing allows you to get site updates. Your email address will be kept private.


Mary D. from North Carolina wrote: .
 wow what great service my order was delivered today and my mom was so pleased she had a mouth full of what she said was the best cookie ever when i talked to her. .


Karen S. from Pittsburgh, Pa wrote:

I ordered a cookie hat for my daughter's birthday up in Erie at one of the colleges, Emily took great care helping pick out the best thing for her birthday.  Jamie loved the "Cookie Hat" filled with all her favorite cookies.  Best little bake shoppe around.


Margo E. from Erie, Pa

Magic Cookie really rocks!!! The browines and crumb cakes are very moist. I don't want not run out! Keep up the good work,


Samantha from Buffalo New York wrote: .
 All I can say is MMMMM……Goood……..and Yummy in my Tummy!


Dave from Erie wrote: 
 Got Cookies? You can bet Magic Cookie does. Wow, these are the best cookies I have ever tasted. My associates at work can't wait for someone's birthday so we get Magic Cookies.  They're waiting for the cookie delivery! The cookies are loaded with chips, nuts, fruit etc. Always fresh. I have served these for dessert after a formal dinner party. My guests tell me the cookies are better than a heavy cheesecake or a fancy ice cream cake. I'll be ordering again, for sure!


Estelle from Millcreek wrote: .
 Best Cookies ever! I can't believe how much these Snickerdoodle cookies taste like how my mother used to make them and the chocolate chip cookies are the greatest!


Debbie Z from Ohio wrote: .
 I have tell you.. I am so glad I found you! My daughter went away to college last year, so my search for a bakery in Erie to send her birthday cakes was on. She received as she put it "The Bomb" chocolate cake that her and her roommate enjoyed!  Thank You!


Coreen wrote: .
 Hi, I just wanted to say thank you!! I took a chance ordering cookies from you for a Christmas gift as I never heard of your company but the recipient said they were delicious! they were gone in three days! Then I had some delivered to my son  at Mercyhurst for a finals gift  he opened them and tried them and said "No offense mom but they taste better then yours...thanks!"so thanks for a great product and service.


Sheri from Florida wrote: .
 I ordered a Valentine's Cookie hat for my mom on Valentine's day.  They were so helpful and my mom loved her gift! A great buy! Try them! You won't be sorry.

Sara from California wrote:

I've ordered cookie gifts three times for my mom in Erie.  Emily was Great and my mom can't wait for another birthday so she can get some Magic Cookies!


Kerri Ann wrote: 
 I ordered cookies for someone at work and they loved them. I recently then ordered a gift for my husband. He raved about the cookies and said they are like good homemade cookies. He has been enjoying this treat for over a week now, and I just felt I wanted to write a note to your company. Great cookies, will order again and will try some of your other treats. Thanks for making a great product.


Jen wrote:

the cupcakes you made for my shower were awesome! So fresh and moist! I will definitely be calling you again. Thank you!


Lisa wrote:

Thanks for the cookie tray for the big game....I had to lock it away so my family won't eat it....HEHEH


Lynda wrote:

love the pies...just like my mom's

Diaria from
 wish i loved in Erie, cause I would be here all the time.....got some stuff from a friend that lived in erie, and awesome stuff! Hurry with that web store!!!!!

Alexis wrote:
Emily's done a fabulous job. Her dad would be sooooo proud of her!