Where Delicious Delights Disappear!
  702 Raspberry Street, Erie, Pa 814-218-3313
  126 West 9th Street, Erie, Pa 
  Erie's Best Cookies!

The Magic Cookie Company Bake Shoppe 

Click here to edit subtitle

What's New Cookie Man!

Join Our Cookie Club!

  • Subscribing allows you to get site updates. Your email address will be kept private.

What's New Cookie Man!

Coming soon!

*Edible Cookie Dough!

*Cupcake in a Jar!

*Edible Cookie Play dough!

*Pie Pops and Hand Pies!

*New Cookie Flavors!

Check our Facebook page for the Coming Soon!

Cupcake Nookies!

A Cupcake baked with one of our cookies inside. 

This was February's cupcake of the Month-An Affair to Remember-A Chocolate cupcake baked with our chocolate chips cookie inside topped with carmel buttercream.  Yummy.

Other flavors include-Lucious Lemon (Lemon cupcake with our Lemondoodle inside)

Peanut Butter Bomb-A peanut butter cupcake with our chocolate peanut butter cookie inside topped with chocolate buttercream. 

They are still in developement so stay tuned.

But you can have your cake and eat your cookie tooo!

Cupcakes on a Stick

The New Magical Find at the MCC...Cupcakes on a Stick.  What could be more magical then a moist yummy cupake then dipped in chocolate then topped with yummy toppings.

Flavors are still in the delevelopment stages, but thus far there are:

Chocolate Chip, Chocolate Chip Oreo, Cookies N' Cream, S'more, Peanut Butter Chocolate, and M&M

Cupcakes on a Stick-$3.50 each

Cake Pops!

Our Cake Pops are a delicious and fun treat on a stick! They are cake, mixed with frosting, and can be dipped in white, milk, or dark chocolate! Then colored sprinkles for you!

Flavors: Chocolate, Vanilla, Peanut Butter, Red Velvet, Strawberry, Lemon, Carrot Cake, Banana Peanut Butter, Peanut Butter Brownie, Brownie, German Chocolate, Double Chocolate

Cake Balls-$1.00 Each